Installation, commissioning and validation
Proving the SIS before the hazard arrives
Installation, commissioning and validation turn a design on paper into a working protection layer. In this phase, the owner proves that the safety instrumented system (SIS), as built and connected to the process, meets every requirement in the SRS. It must be done before any hazard is present.
Plan it early
Installation and commissioning should be planned in advance, with checklists and procedures that match the equipment being installed. Good sources are the manufacturers’ installation and operation manuals, and standards such as IEC 62382 for electrical and instrumentation loop checks.
Test procedures should include both positive tests (the SIF trips when it should) and negative tests (it does not trip when it should not, and it handles faults correctly). The validation procedures often become the basis of the proof test procedures used in operation, so it pays to write them well.
Where validation fits in a project
There are usually several testing phases:
- Factory acceptance testing (FAT) checks the logic solver and its application program before shipping.
- Installation and pre-commissioning includes electrical and instrumentation loop checks.
- Cold commissioning uses water or inert media to imitate the process without chemical hazards.
- SIS validation is signed off before hot commissioning, when hazardous materials are introduced.
FAT is valuable, but it is not validation. Validation can only be complete when all the SIS equipment is tested together, at site, on the process it protects.
Loop checks: documents, inspection, function
IEC 62382 describes three stages of loop checking.
Documentation check. Check the documentation for every active SIS device:
- safety manuals, and installation and operation manuals;
- the certificate or prior use justification for each device;
- loop diagrams and data sheets with calibrated range and trip points.
Visual inspection. Compare the as-built installation with the documents, to confirm the right devices are installed in the right place. Check:
- that valves and flow meters are fitted the right way round;
- that devices are accessible, labelled and tagged, and that protection covers are fitted;
- that glands and connections are tight, and that junction boxes and fuses are in order.
Function check. Test each safety instrumented function (SIF) end to end, from sensor to final element, using a procedure that imitates process conditions as closely as possible. Every requirement in the SRS needs a test that proves it, including:
- trip points, voting and response time;
- valve closure time and leakage;
- manual shutdown, reset and bypass functions;
- the action on sensor faults and loss of power.
Validation checklists
Validation checklists are the best way to prepare for inspection and testing. They should be written as soon as the SRS is complete and the devices have been selected, not on the morning of the test.
A practical structure is:
- a pre-validation checklist, confirming that validation is ready and authorised to start;
- inspection and test checklists for each major SIS and SIF device;
- SIF function tests;
- integrated tests with other systems, such as the BPCS, fire and gas, and packaged units.
Handing the test team a large pile of documents and expecting a quick, accurate record that the SRS is validated is not good practice. Templates should collect everything a tester needs in one place:
- the equipment expected;
- the expected result and pass/fail criteria;
- step-by-step instructions;
- space to record results and comments.
Validation records
The completed checklists become the validation record. When every test has passed and been signed off, they go into the as-built records and are handed to operations and maintenance. Future proof tests and modifications then start from an accurate record of what was actually built and tested.
Any failed test, deviation or temporary measure must be recorded and resolved, or formally accepted, before sign-off. It must not be quietly carried into operation.
Before hazards are introduced, IEC 61511 also expects a functional safety assessment (FSA stage 3). It confirms that the hazard and risk analysis was done, that its recommendations were acted on, and that the SIS is installed, commissioned and validated as specified. See chapter 12: Functional safety audit and our functional safety assessment page.
Summary
Validation proves, with the SIS connected to the process, that every SRS requirement is met. It succeeds when it is planned early, uses checklists and templates that put the right information in testers’ hands, and ends with signed records that operations can rely on for the life of the system.
This chapter summarises the installation, commissioning and validation lessons in our IChemE-accredited course SIS and Functional Safety for IEC 61511 (eLP003).